fbpx

Stopping a Dangerous Article V Convention

The only way to defend our values against this threat is if ordinary people like us step up to make a difference. Join the fight today.

Save the Constitution. GOP and Dem legislators agree: Don’t be conned by the Con-Con | Opinion

BY REP. ILANA RUBEL AND REP. JUDY BOYLE
FEBRUARY 18, 2024

“Washington at Constitutional Convention of 1787, signing of U.S. Constitution” by Junius Brutus Stearns Public Domain We are of different political parties and often disagree, but are allied in our fierce devotion to America’s Constitution. It is now under serious threat from well-meaning people who seek a Constitutional Convention.

There are two ways to alter the U.S. Constitution. The first –and only way our Constitution has ever been amended in its 237-year history – is for Congress to propose an amendment and pass it by a two-thirds vote. Then three-fourths of the states must ratify. Everybody sees the amendment language and knows exactly what they’re voting on.

But there’s another untested way to alter the Constitution. A Constitutional Convention, or “Con-Con”, can be requested by two-thirds of the state legislatures. There has only been one such Convention – when the Constitution was written in 1787. Unlike the amendment approach, a Con-Con opens up the whole Constitution to be rewritten as the delegates decide. Alterations could not be reliably limited to a particular, known proposal; delegates could concoct changes on the fly to anything or everything. There are no set rules determining how the delegates holding such staggering power would be chosen. We would be counting on a dysfunctional Congress to set these rules.

This session, three resolutions are pending in the Idaho Senate calling for a Con-Con: SCR112, SCR114 and SCR115. Advocates will assure you that their sole purpose is to pass a balanced budget amendment or some other benign-sounding tweak. But there is no basis to believe that the agenda can be safely contained. Once a Convention is called, everything is on the chopping block. The Constitutional protection of our rights – free speech, gun rights, a jury of our peers – all could be restricted or even eliminated by unelected delegates. Even the ratification requirement by three-quarters of the states could be removed.

History rebuts the idea that in a Con-Con, delegates’ powers could be restricted to a single item. The original 1787 Constitutional Convention was called solely to ratify the Articles of Confederation, but the delegates ignored that limitation and drafted our current Constitution, including new ratification rules. Top legal scholars across the ideological spectrum, from Justice Scalia to Harvard’s Professor Tribe, have agreed that subject limitations could not be enforced once a Constitutional Convention begins.

If you think this sounds far-fetched, think again. Twenty-seven states have already called for a Con-Con, and once that number hits thirty-four, Congress must convene it. Idaho is one of only seven states standing in the way of a potential gutting of our founding document, and proponents are working overtime to hit the tipping point. Some powerful Idaho legislators have this as a top priority for this session.

The public must loudly tell their legislators not to risk a runaway convention that could gut our precious Constitution. We agree that federal debt should be reined in and government could be improved across the board. But there are many ways to do so without taking unconscionable risks with the document that is the foundation of America’s freedom and prosperity. This is not a partisan issue — it’s a matter that ought to concern all Americans.

Our Founding Fathers created the Con-Con option to use in case the American experiment proved to be a failure and needed a complete overhaul. That is not the case. Our nation is an unprecedented success. America has been a beacon of freedom for centuries and remains the wealthiest, most powerful nation on Earth. We cannot stand by and watch the uniquely inspired document that enabled this success placed at risk. Let’s solve our problems using the many political tools we already have, and not jeopardize our Constitution.

Rep. Ilana Rubel is a Democrat from Boise. Rep. Judy Boyle is a Republican from Midvale.

Related News

Connecticut lawmakers reverse call for Article V Constitutional Convention

Connecticut lawmakers reverse call for Article V Constitutional Convention By Constitution State News May 9, 2025 The Connecticut General Assembly has taken a significant step by reversing its previous call for an Article V Constitutional Convention. Both chambers voted unanimously to rescind the earlier decision, which had been seen as potentially disruptive to established freedoms […]

Read More >

‘Convention of States’ a dangerous, untested effort to rewrite our Constitution | Opinion

‘Convention of States’ a dangerous, untested effort to rewrite our Constitution | Opinion At a time when extreme gerrymandering has created unprecedented polarization and big money buys access and influence, a potentially destabilizing constitutional convention is the last thing we need Mia Lewis Opinion contributor I read Dan Sewell’s July 14 column on the Convention […]

Read More >

Idaho House rejects bids to apply to amend U.S. Constitution through convention of states

Idaho House rejects bids to apply to amend U.S. Constitution through convention of statesSupporters say the move is needed to rein in massive federal debt, critics say the method is uncontrollable BY: KYLE PFANNENSTIEL – MARCH 12, 2025 2:54 PM The Idaho House on Wednesday rejected a resolution that would’ve called for a never-before-used method […]

Read More >

New Polling Shows Americans Oppose Changing Constitution Through Convention

Americans across the political spectrum believe our constitutional rights must be protected and oppose calling a new constitutional convention to change the Constitution, according to new polling conducted last month. Research by J. Wallin Opinion Research concludes that after the tumultuous year marked by a national election, civil rights demonstrations, and a historic health pandemic, […]

Read More >

Guest commentary: Article V convention fails in Idaho

Guest commentary: Article V convention fails in Idaho By DOROTHY MOON Mar 29, 2025 The Idaho House overwhelmingly rejected House Concurrent Resolution 10, aimed at petitioning Congress to call an Article V Convention of States. This is a decisive victory for Idahoans by safeguarding America’s Constitution. The resolution failed by a significant margin, 44 nays […]

Read More >

Call for a Constitutional Convention Veils Anti-Constitutionalism and Portends Political Chaos

Call for a Constitutional Convention Veils Anti-Constitutionalism and Portends Political Chaos The Fulcrum By Pat Merloe Apr 18, 2025 One action or law that violates the letter or established interpretation of the Constitution may simply be unconstitutional, but a series of brazen actions, unlicensed assertions of power that trespass on constitutional text and legal precedent, […]

Read More >

Breaking: New Polling Shows Majority of Republican Voters Oppose Changing Constitution through an Article V Constitutional Convention

A new national poll done by J. Wallin Opinion Research revealed a majority (59.2%) of Republican voters oppose changing the U.S. Constitution by calling an Article V Constitutional Convention. Further evidence in the poll shows the reluctance of Republican voters to take drastic steps to alter this foundational document.  Protecting and preserving the rights guaranteed […]

Read More >

The Wisconsin Assembly just approved a resolution to call a dangerous Article V convention – what happens now?

AJR-77, a resolution calling for an Article V constitutional convention, was passed in the State House last week, February 18. The vote in the house was 60-38. The House is 63 R – 36 D, meaning some Republicans votedagainst this application for a convention.  Wisconsin already has an active convention resolution for the Balanced Budget Amendment, passed in 2017. Former […]

Read More >

Stay Connected

We need your help before it's too late. Join our mailing list to receive important updates and help us mobilize.