fbpx

Stopping a Dangerous Article V Convention

The only way to defend our values against this threat is if ordinary people like us step up to make a difference. Join the fight today.

Fear of rogue convention deters Kansas Senate from aiding crusade to alter U.S. Constitution

Fear of rogue convention deters Kansas Senate from aiding crusade to alter U.S. Constitution
Senate votes down resolution calling for convention on term limits for Congress
By: Tim Carpenter – March 29, 2024

TOPEKA — The Kansas Senate failed to pull together a two-thirds majority supportive of a national convention of states to consider an amendment to the U.S. Constitution establishing term limits for members of the U.S. House and U.S. Senate.

Six states have advanced a constitutional proposition on congressional term limits, which was below the 34 states necessary to call a convention and the 38 states required to attach an amendment to the national constitution. Objections centered on potential of a runaway convention that would dabble in all sorts of issues, but some opponents argued the Legislature should adopt term limits before meddling with Congress.

“It’s another case of we don’t like what other people do, but we don’t have the guts to do it to ourselves,” said Sen. Tim Shallenburger, a Republican from Baxter Springs who voted against the resolution.

Shallenburger, who was in the Kansas House from 1987 to 1998 and was appointed last year to the Senate, said that if reelected in November he would file a bill in 2025 calling for term limits on members of the state House and Senate. In Missouri, politicians can be elected to a maximum of four two-year terms in the House and elected to two four-year terms in the Senate.

Sen. Mike Thompson, R-Shawnee, urged colleagues to rally in favor of the resolution. On Wednesday, the Senate answered Thompson by voting 24-15 vote in favor of the resolution, but that didn’t meet the two-thirds majority required for passage. Six Republicans and nine Democrats voted against the measure.

A comparable convention resolution considered last legislative session by the Kansas House also failed to meet the state’s constitutional minimum of a two-thirds majority. In March 2023, the House vote was 69-54 in favor of a convention.

Thompson disputed the notion “that you’re going to have a runaway convention and its going to come out with all these different changes to the U.S. Constitution.”

However, Thompson said a constitutional convention ought to be convened to require a balanced federal budget given excessive spending of the “deep state” in Washington, D.C., and the rising national debt. Nineteen states, but not Kansas, have embraced the call for a constitutional convention to “limit the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, impose fiscal restraints, and place term limits on federal officials.”

Delegate selection
Sen. Dennis Pyle, a Hiawatha Republican who had supported the concept of a convention of states in the past, said he couldn’t vote for the congressional term limits resolution until firm ground rules were in place regarding Kansas’ participation.

He said that once the convention was in motion the delegates would have authority to amend the rules and the agenda, because “they can do whatever they want.” He said a significant problem with the Kansas Senate resolution was that it didn’t establish who would select the state’s delegates. He’s suggested the 40-member Senate could serve as the state’s delegation to a convention or the state’s governor could be responsible for appointing delegates.

Pyle said there appeared to be a good reason the U.S. Constitution had been amended 27 times, but never by the convention-of-states method.

Sen. Rob Olson, R-Olson, offered a motion to send Senate Concurrent Resolution 1609 back to a Senate committee for additional consideration. That failed 16-22.

“Looking back over my political career, I wish we had had term limits,” said Olson, who won’t seek reelection after 20 years in the Senate and House. “I think one person can spend too much time in one body.”

Democratic Sen. Tom Holland, a Baldwin City lawmaker for 22 years who also decided not to seek reelection, said he was concerned term limits would strengthen the grip of special-interest organizations over the legislative process. He said Kansas voters should determine at the ballot box who served in the Legislature rather than adhere to arbitrary time limits.
“If you have a constant turnover of legislators,” said Holland, who voted “pass” on the resolution, “you will have basically government by special interest.”

Historical perspective
During the Senate Federal and State Affairs Committee’s hearing on the resolution, U.S. Term Limits regional director Shanna Chamblee argued public opinion favored congressional caps on service. Chamblee pointed to a Pew Research Center survey indicating 87% of respondents would welcome term limits.

Chamblee said it was urgent that Kansas join Florida, Alabama, Missouri, West Virginia, Wisconsin and Oklahoma in adopting a resolution calling for a convention confined to term limits of members of Congress.

“This momentum showcases the broad appeal and bipartisan nature of the desire to change the status quo,” Chamblee said.

Guard the Constitution founder Shawn Meehan, a retired U.S. Air Force master sergeant from Minden, Nev., said proponents of an Article V constitutional convention distorted views of Thomas Jefferson and George Mason. He said the nation’s founders didn’t establish the convention option so states could rein in the federal government. Instead, he said, the idea was states could seek amendment of the constitution to address “defects” rather than usurpation of the Constitution.

He quoted Alexander Hamilton, who he said argued constitutional amendments should address the “organization of the government, not … the mass of its powers.”

“An Article V convention is a recipe for constitutional chaos,” Meehan said. “A convention call will lead to litigation. There are numerous states that would litigate to protect their rights in what would become an international embarrassment, further diminishing our Constitution’s illuminating light of liberty.”

Wichita resident John Axtell, volunteer coordinator for Kansas Campaign for Liberty, said congressional term limits wouldn’t “clean up” Washington.

“The problem in Washington is more than just the bad elected officials who have been in office far too long,” he said. “After all, when these bad elected officials leave office, they leave behind the lobbyists, the donors who grew politically powerful, office staff who want to keep their jobs and careers, political party leadership and other participants in this bad legislator’s circle.”

Related News

Inside Mike Johnson’s Ties to a Far-Right Movement to Gut the Constitution

The new House speaker has longstanding ties to the evangelical inspired Convention of States cause. As the interregnum without a speaker of the House came to an end last month, people from across the political spectrum came together, in a rare show of unity, to ask a single question: Who in the world is Mike […]

Read More >

Op-Ed by New Jersey Leadership Highlights Threat of Article V Convention

Just before the new year, New Jersey became the latest state to rescind all calls for a constitutional convention. In doing so, New Jersey takes part in removing applications asking for a constitutional convention that, if it were to happen, leaves the door wide open for a complete runaway convention that has the power to […]

Read More >

Scholars Invite Mark Meckler to Debate a Constitutional Convention

A public debate is slated for Thursday, February 6, 2020 at 5 pm MST in the Lincoln Room of the Idaho Legislature. This forum will offer both sides the opportunity to discuss the merits of the proposed Article V Constitutional Convention, or Convention of States, now being pushed through legislatures across the country.   A constitutional convention could put all our rights […]

Read More >

State House unanimously agrees: CT does not support a ‘world government’

April 30, 2025 State House unanimously agrees: CT does not support a ‘world government’ By David Krechevsky A “world federal government” sounds a lot like a dark web conspiracy theory. For Connecticut, though, it’s a remnant of the past that needed to be purged. During Monday’s state House of Representatives session, the chamber considered House […]

Read More >

Assembly Passes Resolution Ensuring Decades Old Calls for Constitutional Conventions Aren’t Manipulated for Future, Unrelated Purposes

News Release Assembly Speaker Carl E. Heastie FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: March 20, 2024 Assembly Passes Resolution Ensuring Decades Old Calls for Constitutional Conventions Aren’t Manipulated for Future, Unrelated Purposes Speaker Carl Heastie and Assemblymember Ken Zebrowski today announced that the Assembly passed a resolution rescinding all previous applications made by the New York State Legislature […]

Read More >

New Polling Shows Americans Oppose Changing Constitution Through Convention

Americans across the political spectrum believe our constitutional rights must be protected and oppose calling a new constitutional convention to change the Constitution, according to new polling conducted last month. Research by J. Wallin Opinion Research concludes that after the tumultuous year marked by a national election, civil rights demonstrations, and a historic health pandemic, […]

Read More >

Convention of States “Reopen America” Ploy

“I don’t think it’s helpful to encourage demonstrations and encourage people to go against the president’s own policy,” Maryland Governor Larry Hogan, a Republican, said. “It just doesn’t make any sense.”   And yet, that is what is happening around the country as Facebook groups and special interest lobbying organizations are engineering protests at capitols around the nation for states continuing stay-at-home orders as […]

Read More >

Turning to a Convention of States in Times of National Crisis is Not the Answer

Turning to a Convention of States in Times of National Crisis is Not the Answer By Dorothy Moon, IDGOP Chairwoman January 4, 2023 Our country is in a rough place right now, perhaps the worst since the Civil War. Spending is out of control, our southern border is wide open, and Congress seems to be […]

Read More >

Stay Connected

We need your help before it's too late. Join our mailing list to receive important updates and help us mobilize.