Stopping a Dangerous Article V Convention

The only way to defend our values against this threat is if ordinary people like us step up to make a difference. Join the fight today.

Exposed: The Balanced Budget Amendment Convention Campaign

Throughout the 1970s and 1980s, wealthy special interest groups convinced dozens of state legislatures to pass resolutions or “calls” for an Article V convention to propose a balanced budget amendment (BBA). At one point, BBA advocates were just a few states short of reaching the constitutionally required 34 state required to call a convention. However, due to concerns about a potential runaway convention, plus an intensified drive to push BBA through Congress, over a dozen states rescinded their convention calls between 1989 and 2010. 

This pro-convention campaign is the one that has progressed the furthest and it works to add a federal balanced budget amendment to the Constitution. 

In recent years conservative interest groups have revived the convention plan and have persuaded more than a dozen state legislatures to pass Article V convention calls since 2011. As of today, BBA convention proponents claim that 28 states have “active” or “live” applications on the books for an Article V convention on a balanced budget – just six states away from the 34 needed to call a convention.

The American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), a corporate lobbying group hiding under the guise of a charity, has endorsed the Article V BBA campaign and given it a boost. ALEC, which has close connections with and is funded by the Koch network, has become one of the most effective lobbying tools of the conservative convention proponents.

The campaign for an Article V convention on a balanced budget amendment is primarily being organized by the Balanced Budget Amendment Task Force (BBATF) and its affiliate, the Center for State-Led National Debt Solutions (CSNDS). In 2019, former Governor Scott Walker (R-WI) became the national honorary chair of CSNDS. The Balanced Budget Amendment Task Force was previously led by Scott Rogers, who later publicly reversed his position and admitted the real threats of a convention. The BBA Task Force’s campaign for a convention “became less about reforming our nation’s government, but a vehicle to limit and destroy the power of the federal government,” Rogers said.

The proponents for a BBA convention claim a convention can be limited to just one issue – the balanced budget amendment. Unfortunately, though, the Constitution provides no guidelines for a convention would work and what rules, if any, would be in place.

A federal balanced budget amendment itself isn’t all that great of an idea either. It’s imperative to remember that the Constitution is a governing document, it wasn’t created to guide fiscal decisions. Economists have found that a balanced budget amendment, if even enforceable, would sabotage the economy and hurt working families and the middle class by forcing cuts to Social Security, Medicare, and other essential programs everyday Americans rely on. The BBA would also limit our nation’s ability to respond to national emergencies or disasters. A federal balanced budget amendment would not allow for flexibility to respond appropriately to sudden changes in the economy, natural disasters, or national security threats. 

While proponents will argue this is akin to American families balancing their checkbooks, the analogy provides a false narrative and is misleading. As well as building reserve funds, state governments often borrow money to finance building roads, schools, and other public projects. Most American families borrow money for mortgages, student loans, and other investments. Under a constitutional balanced budget amendment, the federal government would not be able to borrow to finance a response to a national security threat or boost economic growth. 

Ultimately, the push for a constitutional convention on a balanced budget isn’t just about fiscal policy – it’s about putting all of our constitutional rights up for grabs. And now, the proponents for a balanced budget amendment convention are exploring new ways to rig the application count in order to force Congress to call a convention.

Rob Natelson, a conservative legal scholar that has advised the Article V convention movement, recently wrote an article claiming that the “true count” to the constitutionally-required 34 states to call a convention is already 33 by adding the BBA applications and other older general convention applications. Natelson’s “fuzzy math” is alarming as conservative special interests try to change the rules – or just make up new ones – on how to call a convention. 

In addition, groups such as the Consumer Action for a Strong Economy, Taxpayers Protection Alliance, and the Job Creators Network, among others, have written letters to both Vice President Pence and Former Speaker of the House Paul Ryan asking them to advance a constitutional convention. These groups believe that, according to Natelson’s math, calls for a convention have reached the necessary amount of states needed to proceed. This is an urgent matter – as many people are contacting some of the highest office holders in the nation to make a convention happen. 

In order to stop this convention, the Defend Our Constitution coalition and other groups have pushed states to rescind Article V convention BBA applications. In the last few years, Delaware, New Mexico, Nevada, and Maryland have all successfully passed resolutions. These rescissions have been crucial in the effort to stop a convention from being called and protecting every Americans’ constitutional rights and civil liberties.

Related News

Georgia groups to legislators: Protect our constitutional rights & vote against any call for an Article V convention

The following letter was sent to Georgia lawmakers this week from a local coalition of civil rights and advocacy groups. Protect Our Constitutional Rights – Vote NO on SR 854 March 11, 2020 Dear Senator, We are writing you today on the dangers of an Article V convention and to urge you to vote “NO” […]

Read More >

Colorado Rescinds Calls for Article V Constitutional Convention

Last week, lawmakers in Colorado took the important action of rescinding all of Colorado’s previous calls for an Article V constitutional convention. This crucial legislation removes Colorado from the dangerous equation many state legislatures have fallen prey to by wealthy special interests looking to start a constitutional convention when they hit the 34 state threshold […]

Read More >

Exposed: The Convention of States, a Campaign to Undermine 115 Years of Progressivism

This proposal calls for a convention with the broad purpose of limiting the powers of the federal government, imposing fiscal restraints on federal spending, and applying term limits for Members of Congress. Embedded within the legislation of this resolution is vague language lawmakers have intentionally placed – thus illustrating the very real possibility of a […]

Read More >

New Hampshire’s upcoming vote to rescind calls for a constitutional convention affects us all

This legislative season in New Hampshire has been busy when it comes to the dangerous push for an Article V constitutional convention. HCR 6 and the call for a constitutional convention was handily defeated in a bipartisan manner with a vote of 318-27.  While this was a great win for New Hampshire because it did not add any new calls to their roster, they still have existing applications for a convention […]

Read More >

Do you know what your legislators are working on?

The Constitution has our rights and values woven through it so carefully and so cautiously because of the immense strength it needs to uphold the pillars of our democracy.   But these rights and the values at the core of our nation, the freedom of speech and freedom of religion, and right to vote, are now at stake. With […]

Read More >

KC Becker: Constitutional convention could spell chaos for democracy

KC Becker, who lives in Boulder and represents District 13, is the now the Speaker of the Colorado House of Representatives. She penned this op-ed on September 25, 2018, while majority leader. We deserve a democracy that puts hardworking Coloradans ahead of wealthy special interests and the well-connected. No one can deny the powerful influence […]

Read More >

Scholars Invite Mark Meckler to Debate a Constitutional Convention

A public debate is slated for Thursday, February 6, 2020 at 5 pm MST in the Lincoln Room of the Idaho Legislature. This forum will offer both sides the opportunity to discuss the merits of the proposed Article V Constitutional Convention, or Convention of States, now being pushed through legislatures across the country.   A constitutional convention could put all our rights […]

Read More >

The Wisconsin Assembly just approved a resolution to call a dangerous Article V convention – what happens now?

AJR-77, a resolution calling for an Article V constitutional convention, was passed in the State House last week, February 18. The vote in the house was 60-38. The House is 63 R – 36 D, meaning some Republicans votedagainst this application for a convention.  Wisconsin already has an active convention resolution for the Balanced Budget Amendment, passed in 2017. Former […]

Read More >

Stay Connected

We need your help before it's too late. Join our mailing list to receive important updates and help us mobilize.